Levels of reflection

Hatton and Smith (1995) defined 4 levels of reflection

  1. Descriptive
    • description of events or literature, no comments or analysis included
    • not considered reflective at all
  2. Descriptive Reflective
    • Some level of deeper consideration
    • limited attempt to analyse based on personal judgement or literature 
  3. Dialogic
    • Includes a ‘stepping back’ from the events and actions
    • Involves a sense of ‘mulling over’ events, a dialogue with yourself and an exploration of your role in events and actions
    • Evaluation of your judgements
    • Consideration of possible alternatives for explaining your actions and hypothesising about them.
    • Links together different factors and perspectives.
  4. Critical
    • Includes the views and motives of others
    • Considers them in comparison with your own.
    • Recognises that things can change with new information
    • Reviews ideas and the effect of time passing
    • Shows evidence that you are aware that actions and events may be affected by multiple perspectives
    • Shows awareness of the influence of multiple and socio–political contexts
    • “Writing about your thinking about your thinking”
    • Recognise and acknowledge the assumptions you bring to an issue
    • Question your own beliefs and values
    • Step back and think about the issue from a distance
    • Occurs over time allowing deeper thought to emerge
You have completed 71% of the lesson
71%